DICTATORSHIP AND WAR
Carlos Antonio López
Residence of Carlos Antonio López and Francisco Solano
Courtesy Tim Merrill
Santísima Trinidad Church in Asunción, the original burial
place of Carlos Antonio López
Courtesy Tim Merrill
Confusion overtook the state in the aftermath of Francia's death
on September 20, 1840, because El Supremo, now El Difunto (the Dead
One), had left no successor. After a few days, a junta emerged,
freed some political prisoners, and soon proved itself ineffectual
at governing. In January 1841, the junta was overthrown. Another
coup followed sixteen days later, and chaos continued until in
March 1841 congress chose Carlos Antonio López as first consul. In
1844 another congress named López president of the republic, a post
he held until his death in 1862. Paraguay had its second dictator.
López, a lawyer, was one of the most educated men in the
country. Until his elevation to consul, López, born in 1787, had
lived in relative obscurity. Although López's government was
similar to Francia's system, his appearance, style, and policies
were quite different. In contrast to Francia, who was lean, López
was obese--a "great tidal wave of human flesh," according to one
who knew him. López was a despot who wanted to found a dynasty and
run Paraguay like a personal fiefdom. Francia had pictured himself
as the first citizen of a revolutionary state, whereas López used
the all-powerful state bequeathed by the proverbially honest
Francia to enrich himself and his family.
López soon became the largest landowner and cattle rancher in
the country, amassing a fortune, which he augmented with the
state's monopoly profits from the yerba maté trade. Despite his
greed, Paraguay prospered under El Excelentísimo (the Most
Excellent One), as López was known. Under López, Paraguay's
population increased from about 220,000 in 1840 to about 400,000 in
1860. Several highways and a telegraph system were built. A British
firm began building a railroad, one of South America's first, in
1858. During his term of office, López improved national defense,
abolished the remnants of the reducciones, stimulated
economic development, and tried to strengthen relations with
foreign countries. He also took measures to reduce the threat to
settled Paraguayans from the marauding Indian tribes that still
roamed the Chaco. Paraguay also made large strides in education.
When López took office, Asunción had only one primary school.
During López's reign, more than 400 schools were built for 25,000
primary students, and the state reinstituted secondary education.
López's educational development plans progressed with difficulty,
however, because Francia had purged the country of the educated
elite, which included teachers.
Less rigorous than Francia, López loosened restrictions on
foreign intercourse, boosted exports, invited foreign physicians,
engineers, and investors to settle in Paraguay, and paid for
students to study abroad. He also sent his son Francisco Solano to
Europe to buy guns.
Like Francia, López had the overriding aim of defending and
preserving Paraguay. He launched reforms with this goal in mind.
Trade eased arms acquisitions and increased the state's income.
Foreign experts helped build an iron factory and a large armory.
The new railroad was to be used to transport troops. López used
diplomacy to protect the state's interests abroad. Yet despite his
apparent liberality, Antonio López was a dictator who held
Paraguayans on a tight leash. He allowed Paraguayans no more
freedom to oppose the government than they had had under Francia.
Congress became his puppet, and the people abdicated their
political rights, a situation enshrined in the 1844 constitution,
which placed all power in López's hands.
Under López, Paraguay began to tackle the question of slavery,
which had existed since early colonial days. Settlers had brought
a few slaves to work as domestic servants, but were generally
lenient about their bondage. Conditions worsened after 1700,
however, with the importation of about 50,000 African slaves to be
used as agricultural workers. Under Francia, the state acquired
about 1,000 slaves when it confiscated property from the elite.
López did not free these slaves; instead, he enacted the 1842 Law
of the Free Womb, which ended the slave trade and guaranteed that
the children of slaves would be free at age twenty-five. But the
new law served only to increase the slave population and depress
slave prices as slave birthrates soared.
Foreign relations began to increase in importance under López,
who retained Paraguay's traditional mistrust of the surrounding
states, yet lacked Francia's diplomatic adroitness. Initially López
feared an attack by the Buenos Aires dictator Rosas. With Brazilian
encouragement, López had dropped Francia's policy of neutrality and
began meddling in Argentine politics. Using the slogan
"Independence or Death," López declared war against Rosas in 1845
to support an unsuccessful rebellion in the Argentine province of
Corrientes. Although complications with Britain and France
prevented him from moving against Paraguay, Rosas quickly
established a porteño embargo on Paraguayan goods. After
Rosas fell in 1852, López signed a treaty with Buenos Aires that
recognized Paraguay's independence, although the porteños
never ratified it. In the same year, López signed treaties of
friendship, commerce, and navigation with France and the United
States. Nonetheless, growing tensions with several countries,
including the United States, characterized the second half of
López's rule. In 1858 the United States sent a flotilla to
Paraguayan waters in a successful action to claim compensation for
an American sailor who had been killed three years earlier.
Although he wore his distrust for foreigners like a badge of
loyalty to the nation, López was not as cautious as he appeared.
López recklessly dropped Francia's key policies of neutrality
without making the hard choices and compromises about where his
allegiances lay. He allowed unsettled controversies and boundary
disputes with Brazil and Argentina to smolder. The two regional
giants had tolerated Paraguayan independence, partly because
Paraguay served to check the expansionist tendencies of the other.
Both were satisfied if the other could not dominate Paraguayan
affairs. At the same time, however, a Paraguay that was
antagonistic to both Brazil and Argentina would give these
countries a reason for uniting.
Data as of December 1988